On the "View From the Foyer" recently, a new visitor wrote:
"I have recently crossed the line from
liberal mormon to no longer believing in the doctrines of the
church. I was raised TBM and served a mission. My wife is
still TBM and is concerned that I have spent so much time
reading and researching "dangerous" questions. I am
concerned about what her reaction will be if I ever tell her
the conclusions I have reached. "
This is a very common experience. It was
suggested that I put together a quick guide to the main issues. I
hope that this helps. I will try to be brief. These issues can be
discussed at great length, but we have to start somewhere.
Making sense of how you feel
- You are not alone! Most
people who join the church do not stay active. Only a
minority of baptisms lead to long-term belief. If you
doubt, there is nothing wrong with you. The believers are
the unusual ones. And the church is not the only
fundamentalist church. Your experience is the same as the
experience of millions of other people. Find a web site
like "Walk Away from Fundamentalism" it
is all very familiar.
- How do you relate to believing
members? It is helpful to recognize the five
types of Mormon. First, a small minority are "genuine"
Mormons. These are humble, sincere, kind, generous,
tolerant, etc., and you wont have any problems with
them. Second, the vast majority are "Conservative
Mormons." The church is their life even though they
have never studied the doctrine or politics or history of
the church in any depth. As long as you show roughly the
right appearances, they are flexible and will accept you.
Third are the "Orthodox Mormons." These are
strongly into obedience, obedience, obedience. The
slightest unconformity bothers them. Be very careful what
you say around them. Fourth, we have "Nazi Mormons."
These who have extreme ideas about what is doctrine, and
try to go further than the prophet has said. If you have
doubts about the church then you have probably felt
uncomfortable around these types for a long time so can
safely ignore them. Fifth and last are "Liberal
Mormons." These are the ones who accept that there
has been bad stuff in the church, but find a way to
believe anyway. They are your friends. They will help you.
And then there are the ex-Mormons. If you see them as
evil "anti"s then you are probably not ready to
leave the church. If you see them as ordinary people like
you, then you are probably an "exmo" in your
heart. Why fight it?
- Is life confusing?
Metaphors may help things make sense. Many of us see the
prophet like the Wizard of Oz. The church is a Great and
Marvelous thing as long as we do not "look behind
the curtain." Or the church is like the film The
Matrix. You can choose the red pill or the blue pill, the
Ensign or the Internet. Or the church is like The Emperors
New Clothes. When we look at the racism, sexism,
inability to translate, DNA problems, and lies about
polyandry, we come to a point where we say "the
emperor has no clothes!" Yet people around us (the
believers) say how beautiful the clothes are, and only
the weak or foolish cannot see them.
- If you openly question the church,
then believers will assume that you have been deceived (by
reading too much "anti" material) or you are
just trying to justify your sins. Be ready for this. It
is how believers cope. Do not blame them.
- Try a different paradigm.
If you are raised in the church, then questioning it is
very difficult. You will not have good answers. Worse,
you will be very badly prepared for the process of seeing
the church in a different way. You will make more
mistakes than you need to., So read a book like Michael
Shermers "Why People Believe Weird Things."
It will give you a new perspective, and hence more
options. It also answers the question "what about
all those clever people at FARMS? They still believe!"
Gaining confidence
- Doubts are good. Doubts
are healthy. Truth has nothing to fear from doubts.
Doubts are how we tell good from evil. You may be
conditioned to see your doubts as a falling away
suggesting that you are going downwards. It may be
helpful to see yourself as climbing upwards towards the
light. And remember that the Mormon church is not the
only church or philosophy that claims light, truth,
strong families, and the rest. There are plenty of other
lights to choose from, many of them with much stronger
claims to truth. So your doubts are healthy, they can
lead you to better things.
- Are you having doubts about your
doubt? That is normal. You are entering
unfamiliar territory, so naturally you are scared. you
are like a domestic animal whose cage has been opened. At
first it is scary. But slowly, tentatively, you will
explore and get used to this strange new sensation
freedom to choose your own beliefs. And there are so many
beliefs out there! If you trust the spirit, follow the
spirit. If you trust reason, follow reason. Either way,
you have no need to fear.
Finding friends
- Web resources can be very helpful.
If you just need some support, and you dont want
people who attack the church, find "The Folk Of The Fringe." They will help. If you believe that some
things in the church are wrong, but you still want to
attend, try the "New Order Mormons." If your
family wants you to come to church but you dont
like it, try "View From The Foyer." If you dont
have to attend, but you still need help, try "Recovery
From Mormonism." Or try them all and see which (if
any) feels comfortable. If they are all too "anti"
for you, then stay in church and find a Liberal Mormon in
your stake. Help is out there.
Your marriage
- If you seriously doubt the church,
then should you tell your wife (or husband) about your
doubts? If your position is not changing, you can afford
to bide your time (for years if necessary) and say
nothing. This is the safest way, but sometimes you change
even though you do not intend to. If your position is
changing, your partner needs to know. They will notice
the changes, and denying it will not help. Sometimes it
is better to face up to it.
- See it from their point of view.
If their whole life has been defined by the church, and
they see you distancing yourself from the church, they
may get very scared.
- Is your married life hell right
now? Take a long-term perspective. Change is
very hard. We all make mistakes and say and do things we
regret. But change in the direction of truth is worth it,
long term. Things will get better. We have all (those of
us who frequent these web sites) been through this.
- Let your partner know where your
beliefs are based now. They will probably be
scared that, without the church, you will drift and have
no moral standards. If you believe in Jesus, say so, and
emphasise this often. If you have common beliefs,
emphasize these.
- Talk! Talk. And listen.
If your marriage has problems, you need to talk. You may
need to close your mouth and count to ten first. But you
do need to talk.
- Do not debate unless you can agree
that logic must rule. Very often one side argues
from the position of faith, and the other side argues
from the position of logic. Nobody wins those kinds of
debates. If you think a loved one might be persuaded, buy
them a copy of Grant Palmers "An Insiders
View" and let them make up their own mind.
- Keep it simple. If you do
discuss problems in the church, keep it simple. You may
be ready for the details, but most believers are not. A
single well-chosen example might make them think. A
hundred examples will make them label you as a raving
"anti." Many people find that Joseph Smith and
14 year old girls is the image that sticks in the mind.
For other people it is that much less than one percent of
the churchs income goes to good causes. Choose your
topics wisely.
- Think of the children (if
you have any). Do you want to bring them up in the
church? If you decide to stay even though you do not
believe, what will that do to them? Will they have to
struggle like you struggled? Will they be taught sexual
equality in the church? What if they learn of the churchs
racist past and try to defend it? What if a child of
yours believes that they are gay? What if they decide
their parent is a hypocrite? What if they go on a mission
and marry in the temple but their heart is not in it?
What if they end up depressed (they are statistically
more likely to in the church)? There are many questions.
You need to think them through before deciding to speak
or to stay quiet.
- Face the abyss. Face your
fears. If the church is everything to your partner, any
doubts on your part may drive them away from you. This is
always a possibility. But avoid black and white thinking.
Even if this "worst case scenario" happens,
there are always other choices. Divorce is not the only
option. You can choose to be friends on different terms.
You can choose to date and woo each other again as new
people. You can choose to be patient and see other good
things in life. You always have choices, there is no need
to despair. And non-LDS marriage counsellors can help.
Shop around. Some are better than others.
Take control of your life
- You are not trapped. You
can never say "I had no choice." Remember that
people only have as much power over you as you choose to
give them. And you dont have to tell anybody why
you do or believe what you do. What you do and what you
believe is your own business. You will have to answer for
it, not anybody else. Even if you choose to obey a
church, that is your decision to obey. So you are always
in control. "Just following orders" is not an
excuse. Habit and previous (often bad) decisions are no
excuse. Learn to trust yourself. Learn to like yourself,
warts and all.
- Some people choose to stay as
members even though they do not believe like the
prophet does. Many of these read Sunstone magazine. If
you choose to stay, emphasize this to your loved onese.
As long as they can rely on you being active, everything
else is secondary to a believer.
- Be true to yourself. If
you are happy in yourself, you can be happy in your
marriage. If you are not happy in yourself, your marriage
cannot be happy. Sure, you are not the person you were
when you got married. Everyone changes. Change is good
all living things change. What matters is how we
handle those changes.
Be positive
- Finally, and most important, be as
positive as possible. Show your loved ones how
your views are good, and better than before. This will
not be easy believers are conditioned to think
that any move away from the church must be a move towards
sin, alcoholism, pornography, drug abuse, violence, and
so on. They needs to see that this is not true. Show
increased love. Do more things with the family. However
you change, whatever you do, make sure that (long term
and on average, because everyone makes mistakes) your new
direction is for the better.